Estimated Reading Time: 5 minutes

Summary: Learn how to choose the best soil mix for your houseplants and understanding the key ingredients for optimal drainage, aeration, and moisture retention. This guide also provides two DIY soil recipes tailored to different plant needs. Jump to the following sections:

• Types of houseplant potting soils that go bad
• Understanding the key ingredients in your soil mix
• DIY potting soil recipes
• Why organic breakdown matters
• Best practices for long-lasting potting mixes

Does potting soil go bad? If you've noticed white fuzz, mildew, a stale smell, or even unwanted pests invading your houseplants, your soil might be going bad. Are you tired of constantly replacing your potting soil and spending more time and money than you'd like?

In this article, we’ll debunk the myths about potting mix ingredients that make your soil less effective. You’ll learn how to choose the right mix to prevent soil issues, pests, and wasted money, keeping your plants healthier for longer.

Types of houseplant potting soils that go bad

Many commercial potting mixes are packed with wetting agents or composted forest materials, which are unnecessary for houseplants and can cause problems. In fact, some of these products can "go bad" in the bag before you use them for your plant. These non-sterile blends tend to retain excess moisture and break down over time. Potting soils that go bad will foster conditions for fungal growth, root rot, and attract pests like gnats.

Contrary to popular opinion, houseplants don’t require forest products or compost mixed into their soil. These materials are better suited for outdoor gardening as a top dressing, not mixed in. When wood and compost are integrated into the soil of your houseplant, they often break down into a sludge-like substance, which is toxic to houseplants and further restricts airflow, compounding the problem.

What to avoid in your houseplant potting soil

Here are 3 things to steer clear of when choosing or making your potting mix:

1. Compost
   While great for outdoor gardening, compost can break down quickly indoors, creating an overly rich, moisture-heavy environment that invites fungal growth and other unpleasant things.
2. Wetting Agents
   Found in some commercial mixes, wetting agents can be synthetic or natural. They retain excess moisture, which can lead to root rot and other issues in houseplants if improperly watered.
3. Wood Products
   Ingredients like bark or wood chips decompose over time, compacting the soil and reducing airflow to the roots. Houseplants thrive better without them.

By avoiding these materials, you can ensure your potting mix remains healthy and long-lasting for your indoor plants. In fact, the best houseplant soils are free of decomposing organic matter and focus on aeration, drainage, and longevity.

The best houseplant soils are free of decomposing organic matter and focus on aeration, drainage, and longevity. Organic materials often lead to mold and fungal activity, and in the worst case, soil toxicity.

Understanding the key ingredients in your soil mix

While this isn't a comprehensive list of all ingredients that can make up a quality, permanent houseplant potting soil, we consider these the top 5 ingredients to keep on hand for any indoor gardener:

Coco Coir

This sustainable, fibrous material offers excellent moisture retention while maintaining a slightly acidic to neutral pH. It’s ideal for keeping roots consistently hydrated without becoming waterlogged.

Perlite

A volcanic glass that significantly improves soil aeration and drainage, perlite ensures the soil remains light and prevents compaction, reducing the risk of root rot.

Pumice

Pumice provides both structure and moisture retention. Its porous nature helps hold water while allowing excess to drain away, ensuring the right balance of moisture and air for roots.

Horticultural Charcoal

Charcoal acts as a natural filter, absorbing impurities and improving aeration. It also retains some moisture, promoting healthier roots and reducing the risk of bacterial growth.

Horticultural Sand

Sand increases drainage by loosening the soil, allowing water to flow more freely and preventing compaction. It helps create an airy soil environment, which is essential for plants with delicate root systems.

The ideal DIY potting soil recipes for houseplants

Choosing the right potting soil mix depends on your plant’s specific needs. While all houseplants benefit from good drainage and aeration, some thrive in drier conditions, while others need more moisture. Below are two essential recipes you can make at home that offer a stable solution for indoor potted plants:

Well-draining mix (for monstera, most tropical plants and trees)

This mix ensures excellent airflow and prevents water retention, ideal for plants that prefer drier soil:

• 40% pumice
• 30% coco coir 
• 20% perlite
• 5% sand
• 5% horticultural charcoal

This blend is designed to minimize water retention, reduce compaction, and allow for maximum oxygen to the roots. This is a permanent soil recipe. With this recipe, you won't need to make any soil adjustments until your plant's roots outgrow the planter.

Moisture-loving mix (for plants like calathea, ferns, and peace lilies)

For plants that thrive in humid environments with moist soil, this recipe provides the right balance of moisture retention and aeration:

• 15% pumice
• 50% coco coir 
• 30% perlite
• 5% horticultural charcoal

This mix holds more moisture while still preventing over-saturation and root rot, making it ideal for plants that require consistent hydration.

Why organic breakdown matters

There’s a common misconception that compost and forest materials in act as long-term plant food, but that’s not the case for our houseplants. When used for indoor plants, decomposing organic materials can actually reduce airflow, harm root health, and cause nutrient imbalances. Nutrients for houseplants are best provided by instant feed fertilizers applied at the time of watering, not from decaying matter. Wetting agents in combination with composting materials can also trap moisture, creating a perfect environment for fungi like saprophytic fungi. While these fungi aren’t harmful, they signal excess moisture and this can lead to disease as well. To avoid this, don't overwater your plants, and stick to sterile, well-draining materials like pumice, perlite, and coco coir.

When organic materials decompose in houseplant soil, they can affect root health, reduce airflow, and lead to nutrient imbalances. You may also notice this activity as mold on the top of the soil.

Best practices for long-lasting potting mixes

1. Drainage First: Ensure your potting mix promotes airflow and allows water to drain appropriately.

2. Skip the Compost: Houseplants don’t need compost in their soil. If used at all, it should be applied as a top dressing, not mixed into the soil.

3. Fertilize Regularly: With sterile, non-nutritive soils, it’s crucial to provide nutrients through consistent fertilization.

Conclusion

Choosing the right soil mix is essential to keep your houseplants healthy and thriving. By avoiding non-sterile potting mixes with decomposing organic materials, and opting for a sterile, well-draining mix, you can prevent common issues like fungal growth, pest infestations, and soil toxicity. Pair this with regular fertilization using products like Big Green Leaves, and your plants will stay vibrant and healthy for years to come.